A Thetford Aqua-Magic toilet can lose water from the bowl, develop odours around the base or leak during a flush. These problems involve different seals in different locations. Use the toilet's full model name to find the correct waste-ball or blade seal, and distinguish it from the closet-flange seal beneath the toilet.

Which seal is actually causing the problem?

Water disappears from the bowlInspect the waste-ball or waste-blade seal and flush mechanism. The correct part varies between Style Plus/Lite, Style II/Residence and Aqua-Magic V/VI.
Water or odour at the floorInspect the toilet's closet-flange seal, floor mounting, drain connection and any water-line leak. The flange seal is a different location and part from the bowl waste seal.
Water leaks during a flushInspect the water valve, vacuum breaker, supply hose and flush nozzle. A bowl waste seal is not a substitute for a leaking water-supply component.

Aqua-Magic waste seal and closet flange chart

The table follows Thetford's model-specific parts diagrams, including their current waste-ball, blade and closet-flange reference numbers. The NewRVParts replacement listings sometimes use a different service or distributor number, so both are shown where relevant.

Thetford toilet model Bowl waste seal Floor flange seal Before ordering
Aqua-Magic Style Plus 34120 waste-ball seal 33239 Match Style Plus (not Style II) and check the original service part
Aqua-Magic Style Lite 34120 waste-ball seal 33239 Use Style Lite's own parts list and identify the original model
Aqua-Magic Style II 42141 waste-ball seal (store: 50027) 33239 Current Thetford Style II parts list specifies 42141, not the Style Plus seal
Aqua-Magic Residence 42141 waste-ball seal (store: 50027) 33239 Current Residence diagram specifies 42141; check toilet configuration
Aqua-Magic V 31708 blade seal (store: 50038) 33239 Uses a sliding waste blade rather than the Style Plus waste-ball part
Aqua-Magic VI 31708 blade seal (check original configuration) 33239 Manufacturer VI diagram lists 31708; verify replacement package and original model
Important distinction: Thetford's current Style Plus/Lite diagrams show 34120, while the current Style II/Residence diagrams show 42141. Older service materials and some parts listings also mention 34120 for other Aqua-Magic versions. Do not assume interchangeability: compare the exact model, original part and relevant service-kit instructions before ordering.

How to identify the right service part

  1. Find the model and serial label on the toilet. "Aqua-Magic" alone is not a sufficient model identification.
  2. Confirm whether the flush mechanism uses a waste ball or sliding blade, and whether the seal is in the bowl opening or beneath the base.
  3. Compare the existing part and Thetford parts list for the actual model. For a toilet previously rebuilt with a replacement mechanism, note any changes made by the service kit.
  4. For a toilet-base leak, verify the floor flange and mounting rather than replacing the bowl seal automatically.
  5. When servicing the toilet, turn off the water supply, use sanitary protection and follow the model-specific Thetford instructions.

Common Aqua-Magic seal questions

Is the Style II seal the same as the Style Plus seal? Their current Thetford parts diagrams specify different numbers: Style II uses 42141 and Style Plus uses 34120. Confirm original equipment and previous service work before substituting.

What is the difference between 31708 and 33239? 31708 seals the sliding waste blade on applicable Aqua-Magic V/VI toilets. 33239 seals the closet-flange connection where a compatible toilet mounts to the floor.

Can a seal fix a leaking flush-water supply? Not usually. A leak from the water valve or vacuum breaker needs diagnosis of those specific supply-side components.

Shop Thetford seals by exact part number

These cards link to the specific NewRVParts listings. Compare the complete toilet model and original part reference before selecting; a similar-looking rubber ring is not proof of compatibility.

Explore the original parts diagrams

For illustrated parts locations and additional service components, see our Style Plus parts diagram, Style Lite parts diagram, Style II diagram, Residence diagram, Aqua-Magic V diagram, and Aqua-Magic VI diagram. You can also browse the Thetford toilet parts directory.

For manufacturer part-number confirmation, consult Thetford's Style II, Style Plus and Aqua-Magic V parts lists.

Save on Parts & Accessories

Sign up for special offers, new product updates, and deals on RV, truck camper, towing, truck, and marine parts and accessories.

About NewRVParts

NewRVParts is an online-only source for brand-new RV parts and accessories, truck camper equipment, towing and trailer parts, truck accessories, and marine products. We serve customers throughout Canada and the United States, with products from trusted manufacturers shipped through a large North American distribution network. Shop online for replacement parts, equipment, and accessories delivered directly to your door.

Shop RV Parts